Thursday, May 21, 2009

Chart: United States Financial Regulators

FEDERAL REGULATORS (yellow highlight)
  1. Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
  2. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)
  3. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Federal Reserve)
  4. Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
  5. National Credit Union Administration (NCUA)
  6. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC)
  7. Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS)
  8. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PGBC)
  9. Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC)
  10. Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC)
  11. Treasury Department (Treasury)
STATE REGULATORS (red highlight)
  1. Conference of State Bank Supervisors (CSBS) --- state bank regulators (50)
  2. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) --- state insurance regulators (50)
  3. North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA) --- state securities regulators (50)
QUASI-GOVERNMENTAL REGULATORS (e.g. SROs) (green highlight)
  1. Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME)
  2. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA)
  3. Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB)
  4. NASDAQ Stock Market (NASDAQ)
  5. National Futures Association (NFA)
  6. New York Stock Exchange (NYSE)
  7. Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB)
AUTHOR'S COMMENTS

The massive government bailout of Wall Street has made clear the need for reform of financial services regulation. Yesterday's post listed many of the top solutions embraced by Congress and the White House:
  • Transferring power over companies deemed "too big to fail" from the SEC to the Federal Reserve.
  • Federal criminalization of mortgage fraud
  • A 9/11-style Commission to investigate the global financial meltdown
  • Federal intrusion into the realm of corporate governance
  • Tougher anti-money laundering laws
Would any of these proposals/bills/laws have prevented the financial meltdown? NO. This is not change we can believe in. In fact, its typical Washington showroom politics - Let's get tough on crime' - 'Lets subpoena those Wall Street Masters of the Universe and make them squirm in front of the camera.'

Take a look at the chart above, and its plain to see what needs to change. The current regulatory structure of financial services is outdated, duplicative, and full of gaps. Credit-default swaps - a financial product with a notional value estimated to be over $50 trillion (3x larger than entire U.S. GDP) - is completely unregulated. Financial institutions are forced to deal with a plethora of regulators - who sometimes engage in turf wars that lead to conflicting compliance requirements - i.e. the current battle over regulation of annuities. The federal government could save taxpayer money by merging certain regulators, such as the OCC and the OTS. In sum, we don't need less regulation or more regulation - we need smarter regulation.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Commentary on the Economy

"The Death of Kings" by Nick Paumgarten in the New Yorker Magazine is required reading for anyone interested in a retrospective look at the global financial meltdown. An abstract of the article is available here (the full view requires registration). Excerpt:

The crisis is the culmination of events and trends reaching back, depending on your perspective...The subprime-mortgage meltdown, the subsequent collapse of the wider real-estate market, and then of the securities based on real estate, and of the firms and funds holding those securities, and of the companies selling insurance against the failure of those firms, and, potentially, of the insurer's counterparties, and so on...Among the dozens of contributors and culprits, real or perceived, are the personal computer, the abandonment of the gold standard, the abandonment of Glass-Steagall, the end of fixed commissions, the ratings agencies, mortgage-backed securities, securitization in general, credit derivatives, credit-default swaps, Wall Street partnerships going public, the League of Nations, Bretton Woods, Basel II, CNBC, the S.E.C., disintermediation, overcompensation, Barney Frank and Chris Dodd, Phil Gramm and Jim Leach, Alan Greenspan, black swans, red tape, deregulation, outdated regulation, lax enforcement, government pressure to lower lending standards, predatory lending, mark-to-market accounting, hedge funds, private-equity firms, modern finance theory, risk models, "quants," corporate boards the baby boomers, flat-screen televisions, and an indulgent, undereducated populace...Much abirdged, a few familiar words will do: debt, greed, hubris."
Most Americans have likely heard of at least one of these issues before. But personal computers destroyed modern capitalism? The amazing thing about this article is that all of the "culprits" are tied in together through a series of encounters with bankers, brokers, and economic gurus.

If you are more of a visual learner, then check this out:
Charlie Rose - A conversation with Bill Ackman



Today in Securities Law

SEC May Be Stripped Of Some Powers. Bloomberg News
(5/20, Schmidt, Westbrook) reports, "The Obama administration may call for stripping the Securities and Exchange Commission of some of its powers under a regulatory reorganization that could be unveiled as soon as next week, people familiar with the matter said. The proposal, still being drafted, is likely to give the Federal Reserve more authority to supervise financial firms deemed too big to fail. The Fed may inherit some SEC functions, with others going to other agencies, the people said. On the table: giving oversight of mutual funds to a bank regulator or a new agency to police consumer-finance products, two people said."

SEC Expected To Propose Shareholder Nominations For Directors. The New York Times
(5/20, B3, Labaton, 1.06M) reports, "The Securities and Exchange Commission will propose new rules on Wednesday that would make it possible for a company's shareholders to elect a limited number of independent directors, commission officials said." The rule "would permit large shareholders...or alliances of shareholders to nominate as many as one-quarter of the directors." And "supporters of the proposal appear to have the three votes to overcome the opposition."

Congress Passes Legislation Strengthening Securities & Financial Fraud Enforcement. Jim Hamilton's World of Securities Regulation reports, "
The Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act, S 386, makes a number of important improvements to fraud and money laundering statutes to strengthen prosecutors' ability to combat this growing wave of fraud. Specifically, the legislation would amend the federal securities fraud statute to cover fraudulent schemes involving commodities futures and options, including derivatives involving the mortgage-backed securities that caused such damage to the banking system...The bill also amends the definition of financial institution to extend federal fraud laws to mortgage lending businesses that are not directly regulated or insured by the federal government...The bill would amend the federal criminal money laundering statute to make clear that the proceeds of specified unlawful activity include the gross receipts of the illegal activity, not just the profits of the activity."

Here is a the full text of Senator Schumer's Shareholder Bill of Rights Act of 2009.


Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Securities Regulators Gone Wild

The vast majority of government regulators responsible for protecting U.S. Securities Markets and investors are honest, hard-working individuals. Unfortunately, a few bad applies fail to abide by the time honored saying "Practice what you preach." These are their stories:

FINRA Accused of Failing to Protect Investors in Sale of Auction-Rate Securities

Allegations of Insider Trading Within the SEC